
Quick Mail Transfer Protocol (QMTP)

INTERNET-DRAFT   draft-bernstein-qmtp-01.txt   (expires 1 August 1997)

   This document is an Internet-Draft. Internet-Drafts are working
   documents of the Internet Engineering Task Force (IETF), its areas,
   and its working groups. Note that other groups may also distribute
   working documents as Internet-Drafts.

   Internet-Drafts are draft documents valid for a maximum of six
   months and may be updated, replaced, or obsoleted by other documents
   at any time. It is inappropriate to use Internet-Drafts as reference
   material or to cite them other than as ``work in progress.''

   To learn the current status of any Internet-Draft, please check the
   ``1id-abstracts.txt'' listing contained in the Internet-Drafts
   Shadow Directories on ftp.is.co.za (Africa), nic.nordu.net (Europe),
   munnari.oz.au (Pacific Rim), ds.internic.net (US East Coast), or
   ftp.isi.edu (US West Coast).

Status of this memo

   This memo provides information for the Internet community. This memo
   does not specify an Internet standard of any kind. Distribution of
   this memo is unlimited.

Abstract

   The Quick Mail Transfer Protocol (QMTP) is a replacement for the
   Simple Mail Transfer Protocol (SMTP). QMTP eliminates any need for
   end-of-line scanning between hosts with the same end-of-line
   convention. It features automatic pipelining and chunking, 8-bit
   transmission, prior declaration of the message size, and efficient
   batching. It is designed to be very easy to implement.


Quick Mail Transfer Protocol (QMTP)
D. J. Bernstein, djb@pobox.com
19970201


1. Introduction

   The Quick Mail Transfer Protocol (QMTP) is a replacement for the
   Simple Mail Transfer Protocol (SMTP). QMTP eliminates any need for
   end-of-line scanning between hosts with the same end-of-line
   convention. It features automatic pipelining and chunking, 8-bit
   transmission, prior declaration of the message size, and efficient
   batching. It is designed to be very easy to implement.

   QMTP is supported by the qmail-qmtpd and maildir2qmtp programs in the
   qmail package.

   In this document, a string of 8-bit bytes may be written in two
   different forms: as a series of hexadecimal numbers between angle
   brackets, or as a sequence of ASCII characters between double quotes.
   For example, <68 65 6c 6c 6f 20 77 6f 72 6c 64 21> is a string of
   length 12; it is the same as the string "hello world!". Note that
   these notations are part of this document, not part of the protocol.


2. Protocol

   A QMTP client connects to a QMTP server, as discussed in section 7,
   over a reliable stream protocol allowing transmission of 8-bit bytes.

   Protocol outline: the client sends one or more packages; after each
   package, the server sends back some responses.

   The client begins by sending a package. A package contains a mail
   message, an envelope sender address, and one or more envelope
   recipient addresses. See section 4 for the format of a package.

   When the server sees the end of the package, it sends back a series
   of responses, one response for each envelope recipient address, in
   the same order as given by the client. The server is not permitted to
   change the order under any circumstances, even if two addresses are
   the same. See section 5 for the format of a response.

   The server is not permitted to send any portion of its responses to a
   package until the client has sent the final byte of the package. The
   client is permitted to close the connection before sending the final
   byte of the package; in this case, the server must throw away the
   package without attempting to deliver the message. However, the
   server must not throw away previously accepted messages.

   The client does NOT need to wait for a server response before sending
   another package. The server must NOT throw away incoming data when it
   sends a response. It is the client's responsibility to avoid
   deadlock: if it sends a package before receiving all expected server
   responses, it must continuously watch for those responses. The server
   is permitted to delay its responses if further data has already shown
   up from the client; while it is delaying responses, it must not pause
   to wait for further data for the client.

   The server is permitted to close the connection at any time, although
   high-quality servers will try to avoid doing so. Any response not
   received by the client indicates a temporary failure.

   A QMTP session should take at most 1 hour. Both sides are expected
   to close the connection after this time.


3. Messages

   In this document, an ``8-bit mail message'' means a sequence of
   lines. Each line is a string of zero or more 8-bit bytes.

   A message is called ``safe'' if none of its bytes are <0a>.

   Implementation note: Here is the intended interpretation of text
   files as messages under some current operating systems. Under DOS, a
   message is stored on disk as

      first line, <0d 0a>, second line, <0d 0a> ... <0d 0a>, last line.

   Under UNIX, a message is stored on disk as

      first line, <0a>, second line, <0a> ... <0a>, last line.

   Notice that both of these encodings are reversible for safe messages.

   In practice, it is very common for the last line to be empty. Many
   existing utilities refer to the last line as a ``partial line'' and
   ignore it whether or not it is empty.


4. Packages

   A package is the concatenation of three strings:

      first, an encoded 8-bit mail message;
      second, an encoded envelope sender address;
      third, an encoded series of encoded envelope recipient addresses.

   Each envelope address is a string of 8-bit bytes. The interpretation
   of addresses depends on the environment in which QMTP is used and is
   outside the scope of this document. Each address is encoded as a
   netstring, as discussed in section 6. The series of encoded recipient
   addresses is in turn encoded as a netstring.

   A message is encoded as a string of 8-bit bytes in one of two ways:

      Encoding #1 is <0d>, the first line, <0d 0a>, the second line,
      <0d 0a>, the third line, ..., <0d 0a>, the last line.

      Encoding #2 is <0a>, the first line, <0a>, the second line, <0a>,
      the third line, ..., <0a>, the last line.

   This string of 8-bit bytes is in turn encoded as a netstring, as
   discussed in section 6.

   Every server must be prepared to handle encoding #1 and encoding #2.
   A server must not reject a message merely because of its encoding.

   Implementation note: The intent of encoding #1 and encoding #2 is to
   allow very straightforward handling of text files under DOS and UNIX
   respectively. The programmer can print <0d> or <0a> and then simply
   copy the file.



5. Responses

   Each response is a nonempty string of 8-bit bytes, encoded as a
   netstring. The first byte of the string is one of the following:

      "K" The message has been accepted for delivery to this envelope
          recipient. This is morally equivalent to the 250 response to
          DATA in SMTP; it is subject to the reliability requirements
          of RFC 1123, section 5.3.3.

      "Z" Temporary failure. The client should try again later.

      "D" Permanent failure.

   The remaining bytes should be between <20> and <7e> inclusive; the
   client is permitted to discard bytes outside this range. It is
   expected that these bytes will, when interpreted as ASCII characters,
   be a human-readable description of what happened. The description
   need not repeat the envelope recipient address.

   Descriptions beginning with <20> are reserved for future extensions.
   In descriptions not beginning with <20>, the character "#" must not
   appear except in HCMSSC codes.

   A server must NOT accept a safe message unless it can store the
   message without corruption. More precisely: if the encoded message
   sent by the client matches the encoding of some safe message M, then
   acceptance means that the server is accepting responsibility to
   deliver M to the envelope recipient. (There is at most one
   possibility for M, since encodings are reversible on safe messages.)
   Deletion of nulls is NOT permissible; a server that deletes nulls
   must reject any message containing nulls. Folding of long lines and
   high-bit stripping are also NOT permissible.

   Servers are permitted to change unsafe messages.


6. Netstrings

   Any string of 8-bit bytes may be encoded as [len]":"[string]",".
   Here [string] is the string and [len] is a nonempty sequence of ASCII
   digits giving the length of [string] in decimal. The ASCII digits are
   <30> for 0, <31> for 1, and so on up through <39> for 9. Extra zeros
   at the front of [len] are prohibited: [len] begins with <30> exactly
   when [string] is empty.

   For example, the string "hello world!" is encoded as <31 32 3a 68
   65 6c 6c 6f 20 77 6f 72 6c 64 21 2c>, i.e., "12:hello world!,". The
   empty string is encoded as "0:,".

   [len]":"[string]"," is called a netstring. [string] is called the
   interpretation of the netstring.


7. Encapsulation

   QMTP may be used on top of TCP. A QMTP-over-TCP server listens for
   TCP connections on port 209.


8. Examples

   A client opens a connection and sends the concatenation of the
   following strings:

      "246:" <0a>
         "Received: (qmail-queue invoked by uid 0);"
         " 29 Jul 1996 09:36:40 -0000" <0a>
         "Date: 29 Jul 1996 11:35:35 -0000" <0a>
         "Message-ID: <19960729113535.375.qmail@heaven.af.mil>" <0a>
         "From: God@heaven.af.mil" <0a>
         "To: djb@silverton.berkeley.edu (D. J. Bernstein)" <0a>
         <0a>
         "This is a test." <0a> ","
      "24:" "God-DSN-37@heaven.af.mil" ","
      "30:" "26:djb@silverton.berkeley.edu," ","

      "356:" <0d>
         "From: MAILER-DAEMON@heaven.af.mil" <0d 0a>
         "To:" <0d 0a>
         "   Hate." <22> "The Quoting" <22>
	 "@SILVERTON.berkeley.edu," <0d 0a>
         "   " <22> "\\Backslashes!" <22>
	 "@silverton.BERKELEY.edu" <0d 0a>
         <0d 0a>
         "The recipient addresses here could"
	 " have been encoded in SMTP as" <0d 0a>
         "" <0d 0a>
         "   RCPT TO:<Hate.The\ Quoting@silverton.berkeley.EDU>" <0d 0a>
         "   RCPT TO:<\\Backslashes!@silverton.berkeley.edu>" <0d 0a>
         <0d 0a>
         "This ends with a partial last line, right here" ","
      "0:" ","
      "83:" "39:Hate.The Quoting@silverton.berkeley.edu,"
         "36:\Backslashes!@silverton.berkeley.EDU," ","
      
   The server sends the following response, indicating acceptance:

      "21:Kok 838640135 qp 1390,"
      "21:Kok 838640135 qp 1391,"
      "21:Kok 838640135 qp 1391,"

   The client closes the connection.
